How Much Liability Insurance Do You Need for a Rental Property?

Laura Olson
Dec 16, 2022

Let's talk about rental property liability insurance. How much is enough for you?  

When you're a landlord, there are a lot of risks that come with the territory. Fires, theft, natural disasters, and even lawsuits can all be potential hazards. That's why it's important to have adequate insurance coverage in place. But how much is enough? And what kind of policies should you be looking for? 

Keep reading to find out more about rental property liability insurance and how to make sure your investment is properly protected.

How Much Liability Insurance Do You Need?

The amount of coverage you need will depend on the value of your rental property and the amount of risk you are willing to take. However, it is generally advisable to have at least $1 million in liability coverage.

There are a few factors to consider when determining your coverage amount. The first is the value of your assets. If you have a lot of equity in your property, you'll want to make sure you have enough insurance to cover that in the event you are sued.

Another factor to consider is the amount of rental income you rely on. If your rental property is your primary source of income, you'll want to ensure you have enough coverage to replace that income if something happens and you're unable to rent out your property.

Finally, you'll want to consider the risk level of your tenants. If you have tenants who are more likely to cause damage or be involved in accidents, you'll need to have higher coverage limits.

Generally speaking, a good rule of thumb is to have liability insurance that covers at least the value of your assets. But depending on your individual situation, you may need more or less coverage.

What Liability Insurance Does and Doesn't Cover

Rental property owners know it's essential to have liability insurance. But what does rental property liability insurance actually cover? And what doesn't it cover?

Liability insurance for rental properties typically covers:

  • Bodily injury: If someone is injured on your rental property, your liability insurance could help pay for their medical expenses.
  • Property damage: If someone has an accident that causes damages, your liability insurance could help pay for the repair costs.
  • Personal injury: If someone sues you for defamation, invasion of privacy, or false arrest, your liability insurance could help pay the legal fees.

For example, liability insurance for rental properties would cover a situation where a tenant accidentally damages their neighbor's property. If a tenant was mowing the lawn and accidentally hit a rock through their neighbor's window, the rental property owner's liability insurance would help pay for the repair costs.

Liability insurance for rental properties typically does not cover:

  • Intentional damage: If you or your tenants intentionally damage someone's property, your liability insurance will not cover the repair costs.
  • Business activities: If a rental property owner uses their property to host weddings, parties, or other events, their liability insurance will not cover any injuries or damage that occurs.
  • Damage to your own property: If you or your tenants damage your rental property or personal belongings inside a unit (like appliances), your liability insurance will not cover the repair or replacement costs.

In short, liability insurance for rental properties would not cover a situation where a tenant intentionally damages their rental. For example, if a tenant intentionally punches a hole in their wall, the rental property owner's liability insurance will not cover the repair costs.

How to Choose the Right Rental Property Liability Insurance Policy

When it comes to choosing a rental property liability insurance, there are several key questions to ask yourself:

How much coverage do you need?

There are a few best practices to follow for selecting the right amount of coverage for your rental property:

  • Take into account the value of your property. Your rental property liability insurance should cover at least the value of your property. This way, if there is major damage to your rental property, you can be sure that you'll be covered.
  • Consider the potential for personal injury on your rental property. If you have a lot of foot traffic or your rental property is in a high-traffic area, you'll want to ensure that you have enough coverage to protect yourself in case someone is injured on your property.
  • Think about the type of tenants you have. If you have tenants who are more likely to cause damage to your rental property, you may want to consider carrying a higher amount of coverage.

What is your budget?

Your budget will play a significant role in determining the rental property liability insurance policy you choose. You'll likely want to purchase a policy with lower coverage limits if you have a limited budget. Conversely, if you have a larger budget, you may be able to afford a policy with higher coverage limits. Keep in mind that the amount of coverage you purchase will affect your premium costs.

It's also important to consider the deductibles associated with each rental property liability insurance policy. A higher deductible means you'll have to pay more out-of-pocket if you make a claim under your policy. However, policies with higher deductibles typically have lower premium costs.

What is the rental property's location?

The location of a rental property can affect the amount of coverage a landlord needs. For example, if you own a rental property in a high-crime area, you may need to purchase a policy with higher coverage limits than a landlord who owns a rental property in a low-crime area. And if your rental property is located in an area with a lot of foot traffic, you'll want to make sure your policy covers slips and falls.

What is the rental property's value?

Property value is another key factor that determines how much coverage you need. In general, the higher the value of your property, the more coverage you'll need. This is because if someone is injured on your property and decides to pursue a claim against you or they sue, the potential payout would be higher. As a result, you'll need to make sure that your policy covers the full value of your property. Otherwise, you could be left with a costly bill if someone is injured and decides to take legal action. Another consideration is how much equity you have in your property. If you have a lot of equity, you could lose more if something goes wrong.

What is the rental property's occupancy rate?

As a landlord, you want to ensure you are protected in case of an accident, but you also don't want to pay for more coverage than you need. If your rental property is constantly changing hands and has high turnover, you may want to consider a policy with higher coverage limits. On the other hand, if long-term tenants occupy your rental property, you may be able to get by with a lower limit. Ultimately, the decision comes down to what makes the most financial sense for you and your rental property.

What is the rental property's age?

Age is another factor that landlords should consider. For one thing, older properties tend to have more wear and tear, which can increase the chances of an accident occurring. Additionally, older properties may not have some of the safety features that are found in newer buildings, such as smoke detectors and automatic sprinkler systems. As a result, landlords of older rental properties may want to purchase a policy with slightly higher coverage levels to protect their investment and personal liability.

Does the rental property have any special features or amenities?

While a rental property with attractive features and amenities may generate a higher rental income, they may also create potential problems. These can include things like swimming pools, hot tubs, and playgrounds.

While these amenities may seem like they would be a great addition to any rental property, they can actually increase the risk for a landlord. This is because if someone were to get injured while using one of these amenities, the landlord could be held liable. As a result, it's important to make sure that any rental property liability policy includes coverage for these special features or amenities.

Where to Get the Best Price on Liability Insurance for Your Rental Property

If you're a landlord, you know that rental property liability insurance is a must. But where should you get it? Here are three options:

1. Your existing insurance agent

The advantage of using your existing insurance agent is that they may be able to give you a discount if you bundle your rental property liability policy with other policies you have with them, such as your homeowners' insurance or your car insurance. However, the downside is that they may not be expert in rental property insurance, so you may not be getting the best possible coverage for your needs since they only represent a single carrier.

2. An insurance broker

The advantage of using an insurance broker is that they are experts in all things insurance and can help you find the best policy for your needs. The downside is that a bricks-and-mortar insurance broker may not have access to the best options for rental property liability insurance.

3. Obie

The advantage of using an online insurance broker like Obie is that they can give you the best of both worlds. They're experts in rental property insurance and can help you find the best policy for your needs.

Here are some reasons why over $4B in property has been insured by Obie:

  • Obie is an expert in rental property insurance, so you can be confident you're getting the best possible coverage for your needs.
  • They offer a simple online process that makes it easy to get a quote and purchase a policy.
  • Obie offers competitive prices on rental property liability insurance.
  • Coverage is available in all 50 states.
  • On average, people save 25% on their landlord insurance policy with Obie.

10 Tips for Landlords to Reduce Their Liability Risks

Even if you choose to purchase your rental property liability insurance through Obie, it's still important to shop around first. This is because rental property liability insurance rates can vary significantly from one insurer to another.

There are a number of things landlords can do to proactively reduce their liability risks. Here are 10 tips to consider:

  1. Require all tenants to have renters' insurance.
  2. Conduct regular maintenance on the rental property and make repairs promptly.
  3. Inspect the rental property regularly and document any damage or repairs that are needed.
  4. Screen all potential tenants carefully and require references from previous landlords.
  5. Have a written lease agreement that clearly outlines the rules and regulations for the rental property.
  6. Enforce the rules and regulations in the lease agreement consistently.
  7. Do not allow smoking on the rental property.
  8. Install security features such as lighting, locks, and alarms.
  9. Keep the rental property clean and tidy at all times.
  10. Have an emergency plan in place and make sure all tenants know what to do in case of an emergency.

These are just a few of the things landlords can do to reduce their liability risks. By taking these steps, you can help protect yourself from potential lawsuits and financial damages.

Get an Instant Quote from Obie Today

If you own a rental property, you are probably aware of how crucial it is to have liability insurance. However, with so many possibilities available, selecting the appropriate policy at a fair price may be difficult.

That's where Obie comes in. Obie specializes in providing rental property liability insurance for landlords and real estate investors. There were no paper applications, lengthy waiting periods for quotations, or endless meetings with brokers.

Get a free instant quote for rental property liability insurance from Obie today.